• ISSN 1008-505X
  • CN 11-3996/S
杨旭, 余垚, 李花粉, 胡义熬, 张承林. 我国与欧美化肥重金属限量标准的比较和启示[J]. 植物营养与肥料学报, 2019, 25(1): 149-156. DOI: 10.11674/zwyf.18024
引用本文: 杨旭, 余垚, 李花粉, 胡义熬, 张承林. 我国与欧美化肥重金属限量标准的比较和启示[J]. 植物营养与肥料学报, 2019, 25(1): 149-156. DOI: 10.11674/zwyf.18024
YANG Xu, YU Yao, LI Hua-fen, HU Yi-ao, ZHAGN Cheng-lin. Comparison of heavy metal limits for chemical fertilizers in China,EU and US and enlightenments[J]. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers, 2019, 25(1): 149-156. DOI: 10.11674/zwyf.18024
Citation: YANG Xu, YU Yao, LI Hua-fen, HU Yi-ao, ZHAGN Cheng-lin. Comparison of heavy metal limits for chemical fertilizers in China,EU and US and enlightenments[J]. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers, 2019, 25(1): 149-156. DOI: 10.11674/zwyf.18024

我国与欧美化肥重金属限量标准的比较和启示

Comparison of heavy metal limits for chemical fertilizers in China,EU and US and enlightenments

  • 摘要: 本文介绍了欧盟各国以及美国部分州的化肥重金属限量标准的制定过程和阈值,分析了我国相关标准制定中存在的不足。我国化肥重金属限量标准是针对肥料种类来制定的,肥料种类之间重金属限量值及限制的重金属种类均存在很大差异。限量标准有国家标准,也有行业标准。不少单质化肥及复合肥标准中没有重金属限量指标,但对由单质化肥配制的水溶性复混肥料则制定了非常严格的限量标准。我国重金属限量标准的制定缺乏理论依据和试验数据支撑,标准公布后也缺少制定依据的说明和解释。美国是根据磷肥及微量元素肥料种类和用量两方面来设定重金属限量标准,该标准由美国环保局 (USEPA) 等机构根据化肥中有害元素对人类健康风险评估模型制定的,并参考了长期的田间定位试验数据和食物中重金属的风险评估调查数据。美国植物食品控制管理协会 (AAPFCO) 根据上述风险评估结果提出了化肥中重金属的限量标准,美国各州则在参考该标准的基础上根据各州法律法规实施。欧盟目前没有统一的化肥重金属限量标准,各国各自规定了相关标准。建议我国参考发达国家的标准制定方式建立重金属的危害风险评价体系;根据大量、中量与微量元素肥料类别及施用量,区分不同重金属的限量,且所有化肥所含的重金属进入农田的限量标准应保持一致。建议制定标准应进行环境、食品安全等调查与长期定位试验,以科学数据为依据,制定适合我国国情的化肥重金属限量标准。

     

    Abstract: This paper briefly introduced the work out procession and the heavy metal limits in chemical fertilizers in some states of the United States and the Europe Union countries, and pointed out the shortages existed in the standards and the working out processions in China. The heavy metal limit standards for chemical fertilizers in China are fertilizer type specific, and greatly different among the fertilizers. The heavy metal limit standards are issued by different departments, including national and industrial standards. Some of the national standards for simple fertilizers and compound fertilizers lack heavy metal limits, but that for water-soluble fertilizers has quite strict limits for heavy metals. The limit standards for heavy metals do not have adequate theoretical and experimental data support, and have no necessary explanations for the basis of establishment after publication. The heavy metal limits in the United States are set up considering both the phosphate and micronutrient fertilizers and their application amounts. Several institutions (e.g. USEPA) in the United State made the standards using the evaluation models for the risks assessment of harmful elements in fertilizers for human health, and referring the data from long-term local field trials and the surveys for risk assessments in foods . The Association of American Plant Food Control Officials (AAPFCO) has proposed limits for heavy metals in chemical fertilizers based on these acceptable limits, and some states in the US are implementing the heavy metal standards based on their state laws and regulations. The EU countries do not have uniform heavy metal limits in chemical fertilizers, and they manage the fertilizers by their own laws and regulations. The standard settings for heavy metal limits relate to various benefits and public welfare issues in fertilizer production and application, soil health, water environmental protection, food safety, deserving our careful thinking and investigation. Suggestion: China should refer to the standard setting methods in developed countries to establish assessment system for hazard risk of heavy metals. The heavy metal limits should consider fertilizer types such as macronutrient, secondary and micronutrient fertilizers, and make one standard for all chemical fertilizers in China. Meanwhile, by referring to the existing research results from foreign countries, it is better to jointly formulate heavy metal limit standards for chemical fertilizers suitable for our national conditions by various departments based on investigation and long-term fixed experiment.

     

/

返回文章
返回