• ISSN 1008-505X
  • CN 11-3996/S
李盟军, 姚建武, 王荣辉, 曾招兵, 宁建凤, 艾绍英. 不同养分管理措施下常年菜地蔬菜生长及氮素径流特征[J]. 植物营养与肥料学报, 2015, 21(5): 1190-1199. DOI: 10.11674/zwyf.2015.0512
引用本文: 李盟军, 姚建武, 王荣辉, 曾招兵, 宁建凤, 艾绍英. 不同养分管理措施下常年菜地蔬菜生长及氮素径流特征[J]. 植物营养与肥料学报, 2015, 21(5): 1190-1199. DOI: 10.11674/zwyf.2015.0512
LI Meng-jun, YAO Jian-wu, WANG Rong-hui, ZENG Zhao-bing, NING Jian-feng, AI Shao-ying. Effects of different nutrition management on vegetable growth and runoff characteristics of soil nitrogen in perennial vegetable field[J]. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers, 2015, 21(5): 1190-1199. DOI: 10.11674/zwyf.2015.0512
Citation: LI Meng-jun, YAO Jian-wu, WANG Rong-hui, ZENG Zhao-bing, NING Jian-feng, AI Shao-ying. Effects of different nutrition management on vegetable growth and runoff characteristics of soil nitrogen in perennial vegetable field[J]. Journal of Plant Nutrition and Fertilizers, 2015, 21(5): 1190-1199. DOI: 10.11674/zwyf.2015.0512

不同养分管理措施下常年菜地蔬菜生长及氮素径流特征

Effects of different nutrition management on vegetable growth and runoff characteristics of soil nitrogen in perennial vegetable field

  • 摘要: 【目的】蔬菜生产超量施肥现象十分普遍,由此导致的面源污染问题日益严重。研究探讨常年菜地的合理施肥技术,明确蔬菜合理的氮肥投入阈值范围,从污染源头控制氮的迁移、流失,对于降低氮肥对水体的污染风险具有积极意义。【方法】本试验采用大田小区试验方法,设置不施肥对照和不同用量化肥配施有机肥处理(N0,化肥氮空白;CON,习惯施肥;OPT,优化施肥;OPT+N,优化增氮;OPT+P,优化增磷;OPT+NPK,优化增氮磷钾),研究了不同养分管理措施对常年菜地甘蓝—茄子—甘蓝轮作模式下蔬菜生长及氮素径流流失的影响。【结果】连续三茬、为期一年的蔬菜试验,共采集径流样品18次。整个试验期间,不同处理的菜地地表径流铵态氮浓度均低于2.0 mg/L的地表水V类水标准限值,且施肥对铵态氮的影响无明显规律性。地表径流硝态氮和总氮具有相似的浓度变化特征,浓度范围分别为0.03~28.43 mg/L和1.06~31.79 mg/L,硝态氮是土壤矿质氮流失的主要氮素形态。施氮不同程度增加总氮和硝态氮浓度,且化肥氮的作用尤为明显。几乎所有径流样品的总氮浓度均超过2.0 mg/L的地表水V类水的标准限值,OPT+NPK处理总氮浓度及硝态氮超标率均最高。对照处理的菜地总氮年流失负荷为30.8 kg/hm2,化肥氮空白处理与对照间无显著差异。其他有机无机肥配施处理中CON、OPT、OPT+N、OPT+P和OPT+NPK处理总氮年流失负荷分别为69.81、54.95、76.6、55.45和90.73 kg/hm2,分别较对照显著提高126.51%、78.29%、148.54%、79.92%和194.39%,且以OPT+NPK处理的流失负荷(90.73 kg/hm2)最高、OPT处理负荷较低(54.95 kg/hm2)。菜地施肥处理的氮肥流失系数在1.47%~3.44%之间,总体随化肥氮用量增加而升高。施肥显著增加蔬菜产量,化肥氮空白处理的甘蓝和茄子产量较相应对照处理分别增加67.50%和114.20%,其他有机无机肥配施处理下两种蔬菜产量的增幅分别为5.1~5.5倍和4.5~5.9倍。相同有机肥用量条件下,施用氮、磷、钾化肥对蔬菜的增产作用明显,且以氮、磷、钾肥用量均最高的OPT+NPK处理的蔬菜产量增幅最大。【结论】从兼顾经济效益和环境效益角度出发,综合分析蔬菜产量、肥料投入成本及总氮流失负荷,优化施肥(OPT)处理可作为常年菜地推荐施肥技术方案。

     

    Abstract: 【Objectives】A widespread phenomenon of excessive application of chemical fertilizers in vegetable production is observed, which has caused serious nonpoint pollution problem. To reduce transformation losses of field nitrogen nutrient imposing pollution potential risk on water bodies, it is necessary to study a set of fertilization technology and determine applications threshold of fertilizers in vegetable production. 【Methods】A plot experiment with treatments of different combinations of organic and inorganic fertilizers was conducted in a perennial vegetable field. There were seven treatments, control(CK)and organic manure(OM)combined with different rates of inorganic fertilizers i.e. no fertilization of inorganic nitrogen(N0), conventional fertilization(CON), optimum fertilization(OPT), nitrogen addition upon OPT level(OPT+N), phosphorus addition upon OPT level(OPT+P), synchronous addition of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium upon OPT level(OPT+NPK). The aim of this experiment was to investigate effects of different nutrition management on growth of crops and nitrogen runoff from vegetable field with ball cabbage, eggplant and ball cabbage mode.【Results】A total of eighteen runoff samples in different treatments were collected during a three-successive vegetable growth period in a year. During the whole experimental period, the concentrations of NH+4-N in different treatments were all lower than 2.0 mg/L, meeting the grade V national surface water quality standard. No fertilization-induced influence was observed on NH+4-N concentration. The runoff concentrations of NO-3-N and total nitrogen in different treatments were 0.03-28.43 mg/L and 1.06-31.79 mg/L, respectively. Nitrate nitrogen was considered as the main form of mineral nitrogen in runoff water of vegetable field, and similar runoff characteristics in concentrations of NO-3-N and total nitrogen were observed. The fertilization increased the concentration of NO-3-N and total nitrogen in runoff water and a more pronounced effect was recorded in inorganic fertilizer as compared to organic manure. The concentrations of total nitrogen in different treatments were almost exceeded the grade V(2.0 mg/L)national surface water quality standard during the whole experiment time. Compared to other treatments, the highest total nitrogen concentration and off-grade of NO-3-N concentration in the treatment of OPT+NPK were observed. The annual runoff loads of total nitrogen in the control was 30.8 kg/hm2 and there was no significant difference between the N0 and CK treatments. The runoff loads of total nitrogen in the treatments of CON, OPT, OPT+N, OPT+P and OPT+NPK were 69.81, 54.95, 76.6, 55.45 and 90.73 kg/hm2, respectively, which were increased by 127%, 78%, 149%, 80% and 195% compared to the control. Moreover, the highest nitrogen load of 90.73 kg/hm2 was recorded in the OPT+NPK treatment and a lower nitrogen load of 54.95 kg/hm2 was observed in the treatment of OPT. The runoff coefficients of nitrogen in the fertilizer treatments were from 1.47% to 3.44% and showed an increasing trend with the increase of the fertilizer application amount. The fertilization increased the vegetable yields markedly, and the yields of ball cabbage and eggplant are increased by 67.5% and 114.2% in the N0 treatment compared to the control, whereas the increases in other treatments were 5.1-5.5 times and 4.5-5.9 times of those of the control. The combined application of chemical nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium fertilizers based on application of same level of organic manure showed more significant increases in the vegetable yields. The highest vegetable yields were also recorded in the OPT+NPK treatment which represented the highest input of chemical fertilizers. 【Conclusion】 From the economic and environment perspectives, the fertilization of the OPT treatment should be considered as a recommendation in vegetable production as comprehensive analyzing the vegetable yields, fertilizer costs and runoff load of total nitrogen.

     

/

返回文章
返回