• ISSN 1008-505X
  • CN 11-3996/S

基于系统动力学模型的猪场粪污管理氮足迹及减排措施分析

Analysis of nitrogen footprint and abatement in swine manure management based on a system dynamics approach

  • 摘要:
    目的 畜禽养殖粪污管理环节存在较为突出的活性氮(Nr)污染问题。为探究其长期演变趋势,本研究从动态视角系统评估了社会经济发展、环保技术应用、养殖规模变化及农业政策对粪污管理过程中氮足迹(NF)的影响。
    方法 本研究构建了针对粪污管理氮足迹的系统动力学模型,设定了6项典型氨减排措施,包括采用低蛋白日粮、在圈舍外安装生物滴滤塔、储存过程进行酸化处理、添加堆肥添加剂,以及改进施肥方式(液态肥注射施肥和固态肥表施后深翻),分析了这些措施单一实施及组合实施的效果。此外,进一步考虑了提高粪污还田率与扩大规模化养殖等情况,共设置9类情景,动态模拟了2000—2050年中国生猪养殖粪污管理氮足迹的变化特征。
    结果 基于人均国内生产总值(GDP)对未来生猪出栏量进行预测的结果显示,受需求增长的驱动,到2050年,我国生猪氮排泄量预计将达到441.6万吨,粪污管理环节所产生的氮足迹保守估计为395.7万吨。这些氮足迹主要来源于粪污还田利用阶段(占比38.6%~74.7%)和舍外储存阶段(占比39.6%~54.2%),其中氨氮(NH3-N)是主要损失形态,平均占比达56.4%。不同减排技术的调控效果差异显著。以2050年为例,在6类单项措施中,低蛋白饲料的氮减排效果最佳,可实现16.3%的氮足迹削减;其次是施肥方式改进,液态肥注射与固态肥深翻分别减排氮7.3%与8.1%。粪浆酸化通过抑制储存与还田过程中的NH3排放,可实现7.0%的氮减排。由于当前我国粪污处理率整体偏低,堆肥过程的氮减排(0.08%)潜力有限。若实施全链条氨减排技术组合,整体减排效率可达35.8%。强化粪污管理各环节技术的协同运用,是降低农牧系统氮损失的关键所在。当把规模养殖场粪污还田率从80%提升至90%时,氮足迹平均仅降低0.76%,这反映出当前施肥方式仍较为粗放,存在污染风险隐患。倘若全部生猪都转为工业规模养殖模式,与基准情景相比,氮足迹可降低约6.3%,其中主要的减排贡献来自储存(115.8%)与圈舍(47.3%)环节,说明我国规模化养殖水平仍具备较大提升潜力。
    结论 未来,我国生猪的氮排泄量仍会呈现增长态势,但系统的氮保留率有望提高。采用低蛋白饲料与改进施肥方式是有效的氮减排手段,全链条技术组合可实现最大减排效益。当前规模养殖粪污管理,尤其在施肥环节,仍有较大优化空间。

     

    Abstract:
    Objectives Significant reactive nitrogen (Nr) pollution issues exist in the manure management process of livestock and poultry farming. To explore its long-term evolutionary trends, this study systematically evaluates, from a dynamic perspective, the impacts of socioeconomic development, the application of environmental protection technologies, changes in farming scale, and agricultural policies on the nitrogen footprint (NF) in the swine manure management process.
    Methods A system dynamics model targeting the nitrogen footprint of swine manure management was constructed. Six typical ammonia reduction measures were implemented, including low-protein diets, installation of biotrickling filters outside animal housing, acidification during storage, composting additives, and improved fertilization methods (liquid fertilizer injection and solid fertilizer surface application with deep tillage). The individual and combined effects of these measures were analyzed. Furthermore, nine scenarios were considered, encompassing enhanced manure recycling rates and expanded large-scale farming, to dynamically simulate the changing characteristics of the nitrogen footprint in China’s hog farming manure management from 2000 to 2050.
    Results Based on per capita Gross Domestic Product (GDP) projections for future hog slaughter volumes, it is predicted that driven by demand growth, China’s hog nitrogen excretion will reach 4.416 million tons by 2050, with a conservative estimate of the nitrogen footprint generated during manure management at 3.957 million tons. The primary sources are land application (38.6%−74.7%) and off-site storage (39.6%−54.2%) stages, with NH3-N being the main form of loss, accounting for 56.4%. Scenario analysis indicates significant differences in the regulatory effects of various emission reduction technologies. Taking the year 2050 as an example, among the six individual measures, low-protein diets exhibit the best reduction effect, achieving a 16.3% reduction in the nitrogen footprint; followed by improved fertilization methods, with liquid fertilizer injection and solid fertilizer deep tillage achieving reductions of 7.3% and 8.1%, respectively. Manure slurry acidification, by inhibiting NH3 emissions during storage and land application, can achieve a 7.0% reduction. Given the currently low overall manure treatment rate in China, the nitrogen reduction potential of the composting process is limited (0.08%). Implementing a combination of full-chain ammonia reduction technologies can achieve an overall reduction efficiency of 35.8%. Strengthening the coordinated application of technologies across all stages of manure management is crucial for reducing nitrogen losses in the agro-pastoral system. Increasing the manure recycling rate of large-scale farms from 80% to 90% only reduces the nitrogen footprint by an average of 0.76%, reflecting the current crude fertilization practices and potential pollution risks. If all hogs are transitioned to industrial-scale farming, the nitrogen footprint can be reduced by approximately 6.3% compared to the baseline scenario, with the main reduction contributions coming from storage (115.8%) and housing (47.3%) stages, indicating significant potential for improving the level of large-scale farming in China.
    Conclusions China’s hog nitrogen excretion is expected to continue growing in the future, but the system’s nitrogen retention rate is anticipated to improve. Low-protein diets and improved fertilization methods are effective reduction measures, and a combination of full-chain technologies can achieve the maximum reduction benefits. There is still considerable room for optimization in the current large-scale farming manure management, particularly in the fertilization stage.

     

/

返回文章
返回