• ISSN 1008-505X
  • CN 11-3996/S

基于HYDRUS与AquaCrop耦合模型的上海市生菜水氮优化管理研究

Optimizing water and nitrogen management for lettuce in Shanghai based on the coupled HYDRUS-AquaCrop model

  • 摘要:
    目的 利用模型预测水氮措施对蔬菜产量、土壤氮素淋失及水氮利用效率的影响,是提高蔬菜生产管理水平的有效途径。本文利用TOPSIS熵权法评价了HYDRUS-AquaCrop耦合模型的预测准确性。
    方法 于2014年4~5月和9~10月在上海蔬菜所进行了两季生菜田间试验。试验设置2个灌水水平:100%充分灌溉(I1)、60%充分灌溉(I2);每个灌溉水平下设4个氮肥施用水平:360 kg/hm2(N1)、300 kg/hm2(N2)、240 kg/hm2(N3)、180 kg/hm2(N4),共8个处理。在生菜7叶期、21叶期和成熟期,分层(0—40 cm,每10 cm一层)采集土壤样品测定硝态氮含量,并收集土壤淋洗液测定淋洗液体积和硝态氮浓度。每7天用叶面积仪Li-3200调查生菜叶面积,收获期调查生物量。利用4—5月获得的数据构建HYDRUS-AquaCrop耦合模型,利用9—10月测得的数据验证模型的准确性,设置多元水氮处理采用验证后的模型进行模拟预测。将淋溶硝态氮(X1)、经济产量(X2)、水分利用效率(X3)和氮肥利用效率(X4)作为评价指标,采用TOPSIS熵权法计算各处理的综合得分,选取最优水氮管理区间作为上海市生菜水肥精细化管理措施。
    结果 1)适量增加灌水和施氮能有效提高生菜冠层覆盖度和生菜产量,但当施氮量超过300 kg/hm2时,深层土壤硝态氮含量增加18.12%~21.12%,硝态氮淋溶量增加9.25%~39.52%;生菜冠层覆盖度和生菜产量分别下降19.39%~22.50%和11.72%~12.05%。2)HYDRUS-AquaCrop耦合模型模拟的不同水氮管理下菜地土壤含水量、硝态氮含量、冠层覆盖度及生菜产量的相对误差(Pe)为−50.35%~81.74%,决定系数(R2)为0.65~0.99,归一化均方根误差(NRMSE)为8.50%~34.72%。在低灌水(I2)与高施氮(N1)的组合处理下,模型精度有所降低,归一化均方根误差为11.51%~20.13%,土壤硝态氮模拟值较实测值低了6.71%~29.82%,生菜产量较实测值高了4.83%~59.08%。3)TOPSIS分析结果表明,采用60%~70%充分灌溉(96~112 mm)配施220~240 kg/hm2氮,综合得分为0.595~0.599,与常规水氮处理相比可减少27%以上的淋溶氮素污染,收获89%以上的生菜产量,达到159%以上的水分利用效率和113%以上的氮肥利用效率。
    结论 HYDRUS-AquaCrop耦合模型可较好地揭示非极端管理措施下生菜生长过程中的水、氮利用和淋失效应,为集约化蔬菜绿色高效生产提供快捷的预测方法。

     

    Abstract:
    Objectives Employing models to predict the impacts of water and nitrogen management practices on vegetable yield, soil nitrogen leaching, and water and nitrogen use efficiency represents an effective approach for enhancing vegetable production management. The TOPSIS entropy weight method was utilized to evaluate the prediction accuracy of the coupled HYDRUS-AquaCrop model.
    Methods Lettuce field experiments were conducted at the Shanghai Academy of Agricultural Sciences from April to May and from September to October in 2014. The experiment encompassed two irrigation levels: full irrigation at 100% (I1) and 60% (I2), which were combined with four nitrogen (N) application levels: 360 kg/hm2 (N1), 300 kg/hm2 (N2), 240 kg/hm2 (N3), and 180 kg/hm2 (N4), resulting in a total of eight treatments. At the 7-leaf, 21-leaf, and maturity stages of lettuce, soil samples were collected from the 0−40 cm layer in 10 cm increments to determine nitrate nitrogen content. Simultaneously, soil leachate was collected to measure leachate volume and nitrate nitrogen concentration. Leaf area was measured every seven days using a Li-3200 leaf area meter, and biomass was recorded at harvest. The data from the April season were used to calibrate the coupled HYDRUS-AquaCrop model, and the data from the September season were used for the model's validation. The TOPSIS entropy weight method was applied to calculate comprehensive scores for each treatment using nitrate nitrogen leaching (X1), economic yield (X2), water use efficiency (X3), and nitrogen use efficiency (X4). The optimal range of water and nitrogen management was proposed to serve as a refined irrigation and fertilization strategy for lettuce production in Shanghai.
    Results 1) Moderate increases in irrigation and nitrogen application effectively enhanced lettuce canopy coverage and yield. However, when N application exceeded 300 kg/hm2, nitrate nitrogen in deeper soil layers increased by 18.12%−21.12%, and nitrate nitrogen leaching loss increased by 9.25%−39.52%; meanwhile, lettuce canopy coverage and yield decreased by 19.39%−22.50% and 11.72%−12.05%, respectively. 2) The simulated values of soil water content, nitrate nitrogen content, canopy cover, and lettuce yield under different water and nitrogen management practices using the coupled HYDRUS-AquaCrop model had relative errors (Pe) ranging from −50.35% to 81.74%, coefficients of determination (R2) from 0.65 to 0.99, and normalized root mean square errors (NRMSE) from 8.50% to 34.72%. However, under the combined treatment of low irrigation (I2) and high nitrogen application (N1), the model accuracy declined, with NRMSE ranging from 11.51% to 20.13%. Under these conditions, the simulated soil nitrate nitrogen content was 6.71% to 29.82% lower than the measured values, and the simulated lettuce yield was 4.83%−59.08% higher than the measured values. 3) TOPSIS analysis results indicated that applying 220−240 kg/hm2 of nitrogen fertilizer under 60%−70% full irrigation (96−112 mm) achieved comprehensive scores of 0.595−0.599. Compared with conventional water-nitrogen management, this strategy reduced nitrogen leaching losses by over 27%, maintained more than 89% of the lettuce yield, and achieved over 159% of the water use efficiency and over 113% of the nitrogen use efficiency.
    Conclusions The coupled HYDRUS-AquaCrop model can effectively reveal the water and nitrogen utilization and leaching effects during lettuce growth under non-extreme management practices, providing a rapid prediction method for green and efficient intensive vegetable production.

     

/

返回文章
返回