• ISSN 1008-505X
  • CN 11-3996/S

绿肥联合磷矿粉施用对稻田镉污染的影响

Effects of green manure combined with phosphate rock powder on the reduction of cadmium contamination in paddy fields

  • 摘要:
    目的 研究绿肥 (GM)种类和磷矿粉用量对降低土壤有效镉 (Cd)含量和减少水稻Cd吸收的影响,为水稻安全生产提供科学依据。
    方法 于2021年11月至2022年11月在湖南开展早稻−晚稻盆栽试验,设置冬闲 (CK)和冬种紫云英 (MV)、毛叶苕子 (HV)、箭筈豌豆 (CV)、黑麦草 (PR)、油菜 (ER) 6个处理,每个绿肥类型下设3个磷矿粉用量 (P)水平:P0 (0 kg/hm2)、P1 (1650 kg/hm2)、P2 (3300 kg/hm2),共计18个处理。采集早、晚稻成熟期土壤和糙米样品,分别测定土壤基本理化性质、土壤有效Cd (ACd)及糙米Cd (BCd)含量。
    结果 绿肥种类、磷矿粉施用水平及其交互作用对土壤理化性质、有效Cd含量及糙米Cd积累均产生显著影响 (P<0.05)。所有处理均提高土壤pH,其中早稻土壤速效钾,晚稻土壤速效磷、有机质及阳离子交换量受处理效应影响显著 (P<0.05)。与CK-P0相比,CK-P2处理早稻土壤有效Cd含量降低42.15%;各绿肥P0处理土壤有效镉变化范围为−30.53%~22.63%,P1处理降幅为15.24%~28.80%,P2处理降幅为40.82%~60.79%,降幅显著高于对应P1处理,最大降幅出现在HV-P2处理。相比于CK-P0,CK-P2处理晚稻土壤有效Cd含量降低38.16%;5个绿肥P0处理晚稻土壤有效Cd含量降幅为−4.26%~97.43%,P2处理降幅为−16.51%~14.14%,最大降幅出现在CK-P2处理。CK-P1、CK-P2处理早稻糙米Cd含量分别较CK-P0处理降低了58.70%、59.93%,单独绿肥处理降低了63.09%~87.39%,绿肥磷矿粉配合处理降低了76.16%~90.95%,其中MV-P2、HV-P1、HV-P2、CV-及PR-所有处理的早稻糙米镉含量均低于0.2 mg/kg的安全阈值。至于晚稻糙米Cd含量,CK-P2处理较CK-P0处理降低50.22%,P1、P2处理的降幅分别在34.85%~69.93%和59.20%~64.26%,5种绿肥P2处理的糙米Cd含量均低于0.2 mg/kg。随机森林结果表明,土壤有效Cd含量的主要影响因子为磷矿粉用量和pH,糙米Cd含量的主要影响因子为绿肥种类和pH。
    结论 绿肥种植能够显著且稳定地降低糙米Cd含量,但其降低土壤有效Cd含量的效果存在一定不确定性;单独施用磷矿粉显著降低土壤有效Cd含量,其抑制糙米Cd积累效果弱于绿肥处理;绿肥联合磷矿粉施用通过交互效应进一步强化降低土壤有效Cd含量的效果,最终使糙米Cd含量降至安全阈值以下。早稻的最佳处理为冬种毛叶苕子配施3300 kg/hm2磷矿粉处理,晚稻为冬种黑麦草配施3300 kg/hm2磷矿粉处理。

     

    Abstract:
    Objectives This study aimed to investigate the effects of green manure (GM) species and phosphate rock powder (P) application rates on reducing soil available cadmium (Cd) content and cadmium uptake by rice, so as to provide a scientific basis for rice safe production.
    Methods A pot experiment was conducted in a double-cropping rice area in Hunan Province from November 2021 to November 2022. Six winter treatments were established: winter fallow (CK), Chinese milk vetch (MV), hairy vetch (HV), common vetch (CV), perennial ryegrass (PR), and rape (ER), along with three P application levels: P0 (0 kg/hm2), P1 (1650 kg/hm2), and P2 (3300 kg/hm2), resulting in a total of 18 treatments. Soil and brown rice samples were collected at the maturity stage of early and late rice. Soil physicochemical properties, available cadmium (ACd) and brown rice cadmium (BCd) content were determined.
    Results Green manure species, P application rate and their interaction significantly effected soil physicochemical properties, ACd and BCd content (P<0.05). All treatments increased soil pH, and available K in early-season rice soil, as well as available P, organic matter and cation exchange capacity in late-season rice soil, were significantly affected by the treatments (P<0.05). Compared with the CK-P0 treatment, the CK-P2 treatment reduced ACd in early-season rice soil by 42.15%. Under green manure treatments, changes in ACd ranged from −30.53% to 22.63% under P0, reductions ranged from 15.24% to 28.80% under P1, and from 40.82% to 60.79% under P2. The reductions under P2 were significantly greater than those under the corresponding P1 treatments, with the greatest decrease observed in HV-P2. In late-season rice soil, ACd under CK-P2 decreased by 38.16% compared with CK-P0. The reductions in ACd ranged from −4.26% to 97.43% under the green manure P0 treatments and from −16.51% to 14.14% under the P2 treatments, with the greatest reduction observed under CK-P2. For early rice, BCd concentrations under CK-P1 and CK-P2 were reduced by 58.70% and 59.93%, respectively, relative to CK-P0. Green manure alone reduced BCd by 63.09%–87.39%, while the combined application of green manure and phosphate rock powder reduced BCd by 76.16%–90.95%. The BCd concentrations in MV-P2, HV-P1, HV-P2, and all CV and PR treatments were below the safety threshold of 0.2 mg/kg. For late rice, BCd under CK-P2 decreased by 50.22% compared with CK-P0. The reductions under P1 and P2 treatments ranged from 34.85% to 69.93% and from 59.20% to 64.26%, respectively. BCd concentrations in all green manure P2 treatments were below 0.2 mg/kg. Random forest analysis showed that phosphate rock powder application rate and soil pH were the primary factors affecting ACd, whereas green manure species and soil pH were the major factors influencing BCd.
    Conclusions Winter cultivation of green manure significantly and consistently reduced Cd accumulation in brown rice, although its effect on reducing soil available Cd varied among species. Application of phosphate rock powder alone effectively decreased soil available Cd but was less effective than green manure in suppressing Cd accumulation in brown rice. The combined application of green manure and phosphate rock powder further enhanced Cd immobilization in soil through their interactive effects, ultimately reducing BCd concentrations below the food safety threshold. Among the tested treatments, HV-P2 was the optimal combination for early rice, whereas PR-P2 was the most effective treatment for late rice.

     

/

返回文章
返回